From the ethical point of view, the Enron scandal unveiled the most significant part of legislation that is associated with the oversight of corporate ethics. Ethical Issues of the Enron Scandal: A potential solution Enron's entire scandal was based on a foundation of lies characterized by the most brazen and most unethical accounting and business practices that will forever have a place in the hall of scandals that have shamed American history. The topics that will be discussed are ethical issues, the stakeholders and their issues in the case, an analysis from a stakeholders’ perspective, Enron’s corporate culture and their commitment to social responsibility, and Enron’s view of corporate governance. Top Enron executives sold their company stock prior to the companys downfall, whereas lower-level employees were prevented from selling their stock due to 401K restrictions. Ethics in business and shareholders desires for profitability are not always put on the same pedestal, and it is the responsibility of the executive management to ensure ethics surpass profitability. It was developed as a course to study in the 1970s. A lot of people have suffered, not the least of whom are the shareholders and pensioners who lost it all. You may opt-out by. Lessons from the Enron Scandal 1. Markkula Center for Applied Ethics 3. Enron was once ranked the sixth-largest energy company in the world. Values matter: Ignoring trouble spots or blaming underlings is unacceptable. Clearly, Enron was a poor investment. From 1998 to 2000, Enron’s revenues grew from about $31 billion to more than $100 billion, making it the seventh-largest company of the Fortune 500. Focus Areas 4. Business Ethics 5. Business Ethics Resources 6. The Enron Scandal and Ethical Issues Enron Corporation is an energy trading, natural gas, and electric public-service corporations company located in Houston, Texas that had around 21,000 employees by mid-2001, before it went bankrupt. Ethical and political analyses. In 1985, Enron was born. My features and my columns have also won several national awards. Fastow and his wife, Lea, both pleaded guilty to charges against them. The word ‘business ethics’ came into common use in the early 1970s in the United States. The Enron Corporation was created in 1985 out a merger of two major gas pipeline companies. $35.80 for a 2-page paper. Unprecedented actions such as teenage smoking were dealt with by the government. The foundation that certain principles could be applied to business activities which were laid down by theologians and philosophers led to business lecturers start teaching and writing about corporate social responsibility (CSR) which can be defined as a form of corporate self-regulation integrated into a business model. In the 90s it was all about the institutionalization of business ethics. Enron Scandals and the Lack of Ethics Involved Analysis of Issues Related to Social Contract Theory and Kant’s Categorical. Ethical Lessons Learned from Corporate Scandals Ethics is about behavior and in the face of dilemma; it is about doing the right thing. Now, though, an appeals court has reduced Skilling’s sentencing because it said that the trial court had miscalculated the codified penalty. Ideally, managerial leaders and their people will act ethically as a result of their internalized virtuous core values. Enron Corporation, an energy company based in Houston, Texas, was involved in one of the most devious economic scandals. Enron Scandals and the Lack of Ethics Involved Analysis of Issues Related to Social Contract Theory and Kant’s Categorical. The use of complex and creative accounting methods by Enron’s management wa… Without a doubt, corporate cultures must reward ethical conduct and penalize wrongdoing at every turn. But with each passing scandal, new rules and codes emerge that surpass those of the past. On October 22, 2001 Enron announces that the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has launched a formal investigation into its related party’s transactions. Critically Review Enron Scandal. Business ethics became a common expression thanks to the media and it was no longer considered as an oxymoron. A case of John DeLorean, the founder of the DeLorean Motor Company who goes Ireland to builds his dream car. It'd become one of America's largest in just a decade with accolades like "America's most innovative company." Ultimately, former Enron CEO Jeffrey Skilling received the harshest sentence of anyone involved in the Enron scandal. Although business ethics was seen to have become more institutionalized in the 1990s, in the 2000s evidence came out that more than a few business executives and managers had not been compiling with the public’s desire for high ethical standards. It provides guidelines and requirements for Accounting, financial disclosure, the ethical behavior of … When Enron's scandal became public, the audit committee's conflicts of interest were regarded with suspicion. August 2001 - Sherron Watkins, a vice president, warns Lay that the company could "implode in a wave of accounting scandals." In the 1980s, the Defence Industry Initiative on Business Ethics and Conduct (DII) which was developed to give a guide to organisations about support for ethical conduct. The Enron Scandal & Ethics. It's simply a milestone. The key to creating a just and ethical corporate culture is to breed fair and lasting business principles. Off-balance-sheet financing called ‘special-purpose entities’ (SPEs) which were the write-offs and the losses not disclosed were the main thing that turned Enron into a disaster. The Enron Scandal and Ethical Issues. A case of John DeLorean, the founder of the DeLorean Motor Company who goes Ireland to builds his dream car. Thesis Statement: Enron violated three ethical principles (the transparency principle, the fiduciary principle, and the fairness principle) of the Global Business Standard Codex in its management practices, leading to its collapse in December 2001. At the time, Enron was ranked the sixth-largest energy company in the world. Most of the SPEs at Enron were alleged to be entities in name only, and that Enron funded them with its own stock and maintained control over them. Enron ging dazu über, solche Geschäfte mit in ausländischen Steuerparadiesen gegründeten anonymen „Offshore“-Gesellschaften abzuschließen, die unter der Kontrolle von Enron oder dessen Führungskräften standen, aber nicht in den Konsolidierungskreis des Konzernabschlusses des Enron-Konzerns einbezogen wurden. Enron scandal, series of events that resulted in the bankruptcy of the U.S. energy, commodities, and services company Enron Corporation and the dissolution of Arthur Andersen LLP, which had been one of the largest auditing and accounting companies in the world. Before 1960, the United States went through several difficult phases of wondering what the concept of capitalism was. Enron’s aggressive employee culture was motivated by the desire to improve their financial position. Arthur Andersen Ltd. Case Study The Aftermath of the Enron Scandal Enron: Failure and Scandal How Ethics May Have Played a Role in Enron's Way of Doing Business Enron Enron Company's Unethical Business Research Practices Review: “Close Encounters: Communication in Relationships” by Guerrero, Andersen and Afifi Hanson: The Enron scandal is the most significant corporate collapse in the United States since the failure of many savings and loan banks during the 1980s. Learn how your comment data is processed. Introduction Enron Corporation was an American energy, commodities, and services company based in Houston, Texas. • Investors lost some 60 billion dollars within a few days; for many it meant losing their old-age security. For nine years, Since the late 1990s, I’ve covered energy, beginning with the rise and fall of Enron — first as a magazine writer before becoming a columnist and editor. Even nearly twenty years on, this scandal and the ensuring collapse of one of the world’s most respected accounting firms stands as the single best example of just how badly things can go wrong. BP’s Big Writedown: A Harbinger For A Declining Industry Or Of A Struggling Company? Then, as the scandal was uncovered, the shares plummeted over several months to an all-time low of $0.26 in November 2001.What was particularly worrying about the scandal was how such a large-scale deception scheme was successfully pulled off for so long, and how regulatory authorities failed to take action in order to stop it. Companies that live and breathe their missions, by contrast, will get recognized by both the retail and capital markets. or ethics class, the “Enron Scandal” as a lot might say is brought up to teach all the students a lesson about ethics and how regulations in the accounting world were enacted. Enron shares were worth $90.75 at their peak but dropped to $0.67 immediately after the scandal was revealed and the company collapsed. THE ETHICAL DILEMMAS. Enron worked to make their losses look like less than they actually were, and “cooked the books” to … The company was also a commodities and services organization that served much of the country. The wholesale energy income represented about 93 percent of 2000 revenues for Enron, with another 4 percent coming from natural gas and electricity. This era was the Reagan-Bush era where the belief of self-regulation was seen to be in the public’s interest. For those not familiar with the Enron scandal, most of the top executives were tried for fraud after it was revealed in November 2001 that the companys earned had been overstated by several hundred million dollars. Aristotle said, “The end and purpose of the polis is the good life”. It is important to understand the reasons behind the Enron scandal and look at how the events unfolded in this case. Such a system allows management to address and handle issues in a holistic way to ensure strong ethical health. Als das Konstrukt in sich zusammenfiel, stürzte die Aktie ab und Investoren sowie Fondsmanager reichten Klage ein. SEE ALSO: ENRON, ETHICS AND THE SLOW DEATH OF AMERICAN DEMOCRACY. The Enron scandal is the most prominent bankruptcy reorganization ever witnessed. Members and Candidates must not knowingly participate or assist in and must dissociate from any violation of such laws, rules, or regulations. It is in the best ethical practices to fully disclose the financial situation as correctly as possible to investors even if it reflects a bad financial position. EY & Citi On The Importance Of Resilience And Innovation, How Digital Workflows Helped Save Basketball During The Pandemic, Impact 50: Investors Seeking Profit — And Pushing For Change, Michigan Economic Development Corporation With Forbes Insights, Guyana’s Election Controversy Threatens Its Energy Future, Chesapeake Energy Finally Succumbs With Chapter 11 Filing, Deloitte: COVID-19 Fallout Demands That U.S. Shale Completely Transform Its Operations, The Oil And Gas Situation: The E&P Sector Faces A Reckoning. Enron Corporation is an energy trading, natural gas, and electric utilities company located in Houston, Texas that had around 21,000 employees by mid-2001, before it went bankrupt. The answer is that Enron is a well-documented story and we can apply our approach with the great benefit of hindsight to show how the end result could have been predicted. Critics believed they might constitute fraudulent financial reporting because they didn’t accurately represent the company’s true financial condition. For example, the former CEO of Tyco Dennis Kozlowski was indicted on thirty-eight counts of misappropriating $170 million of Tyco funds and netting $430 million from inappropriate sales of stock. Dynegy terminated the deal. I now cover all of those issues on a global basis, especially for the African and Asian regions. Smith in his The Wealth of Nations commented, “All for ourselves, and nothing for other people, seems, in every age of the world, to have been the vile maxim of the masters of mankind.” Ethical misconduct has become a key concern in business today. The company’s failure in 2001 represents the biggest business bankruptcy ever while also spotlighting corporate America’s moral failings. Enron scandal 1. Members and Candidates must not knowingly participate or assist in and must dissociate from any violation of such laws, rules, or regulations. Email: firstname.lastname@example.org, © 2020 Forbes Media LLC. During 2001, when a series of revelations were revealed involving improper accounting procedures bordering on fraud committed throughout the 1990s involving Enron and its accounting company Arthur Andersen, Enron suffered the largest bankruptcy in history which has been surpassed by those of WorldCom during 2002 and Lehman Brothers during 2008. Enron used the special enterprise entities as a way of hiding its huge amounts of debt from its investors. "But, there is no panacea, and I think we will continue to see abuses and excesses -- but hopefully fewer.”. Your email address will not be published. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. PBS ethics program re-examines Enron scandal Accounting misdeeds at Houston firm now a case study in bad behavior Chris Tomlinson Jan. 19, 2017 Updated: Jan. 19, 2017 8:15 a.m. Der Konzern wies die „Einnahmen“ aus … Since the late 1990s, I’ve covered energy, beginning with the rise and fall of Enron — first as a magazine writer before becoming a columnist and editor. Why pick Enron? Lea was sentenced to one year for helping her husband hide income from the government. It was based in Houston, Texas. The firm after been found guilty of criminal charges in the way the auditing of Enron was conducted gave up their licenses to practice in the US. Skilling brought in a system where employees were appraised every six months and if the employees ranked in the bottom 20 percent they were let go. Enron was a company that was able to gain by supplying the bringing of gas to public-service corporation companies and concerns at the just value m… Business Ethics and Social Responsibility. That's right, I worked as part of the CFO's SWOT team at Enron until news of the company's financial scandal came crashing down, and with it, everything I believed about business and leadership. Ideally, managerial leaders and their people will act ethically as a result of their internalized virtuous core values. The devastation of the Enron scandal can also be seen at the security level. My stories have appeared in, and have been cited by, dozens of publications and broadcasts. But, by the end of 2001, the Enron scandal's ethics quagmire shattered that illusion as $74 billion was lost and lives were destroyed in the aftermath. Their Q & A appears below: Nakayama: What do you think are the most important lessons to be learned from the Enron scandal? Antibusiness attitude developed as people attacked the individuals in power that got benefits from the economic and political sides of society that they controlled. Through the 1950s, the New Deal advanced into the Fair Deal which was an ambitious set of proposals put forward by President Harry S Truman. PBS ethics program re-examines Enron scandal Accounting misdeeds at Houston firm now a case study in bad behavior Chris Tomlinson Jan. 19, 2017 Updated: Jan. 19, 2017 8:15 a.m. Moral issues that were related to business were now addressed in churches and mosques. the scandals perpetrated by Enron and Arthur Ande rsen affected the entire business world. Proposals included prohibition of cigarette advertising, and stopping sports events from using cigarette logos during advertisement. Levitt who ineffectively pushed many reforms which could have prevented the accounting ethics scandals demonstrated by Enron and WorldCom. “So, even if you can't really regulate ethics, the fact that more people are more closely scrutinizing board behavior encourages directors to be more responsible,” says Mary Driscoll, an analyst with Standard & Poor’s. Meaningful cultures will implore workers to do the right thing. Commentators attributed the mismanagement behind Enron's fall to a variety of ethical and political-economic causes. Enron is an attention-grabbing example in business ethics studies as it has been described as being a perfect example of an unethical (Culpan and Trussel 2005) and systemically psychopathic business.Lauded by Fortune magazine, among others, as one of the most innovative and admired corporations in America (Van Niel and Rapoport 2004), Enron was a very large US energy corporation, … The devastation of the Enron scandal can also be seen at the security level. Businesses were asked to work more thoroughly with the government to help increase family income. It's the foundation to which boards, managers and workers rely when they reach a fork in the road. This cost Enron over $1.2 billion in equity in late 2001. Enron is the poster child for such distorted behavior. One of the few revenue-generating assets that the Andersen firm still has is Q Centre, which is a conference and training facility outside of Chicago. • Within a short time, it grew into the largest gas provider in Britain and America. These accounting scandals really confirmed to the public that falsifying financial reports and reaping questionable benefits had become part of the culture of many companies. In its role as Enron’s auditor, they were responsible for make sure that Enron’s financial statements and internal bookkeeping were accurate. ENRON - the company • Enron was a worldwide leading energy concern with its seat in Houston, Texas. However, these types of isolated, terrible investment returns should not discourage market participants from continuing to invest moving … Ethics And Moral Issues In The Enron Scandal 931 Words 4 Pages In this Enron Scandal ,several moral issues and values are being discussed .The moral issues is the misconduct of code of ethics by management level of a corporation , violation of code of professional ,ethical dilemma that faced by a management level when involved own interest . Its gross in the twelvemonth 2000 was more than $ 100 billion and named as “ America ‘s most advanced companies for six back-to-back old ages by Fortune. • 4500 employees lost their jobs. Enron Corporation, an energy company based in Houston, Texas, was involved in one of the most devious economic scandals. of the Enron scandal is the complicity of so many highly regarded Wall Street firms in enabling Enrons fraud as well as being partners to it. Accenture which is a consultancy firm separated from the accountancy side of Arthur Andersen in 1987 and renamed themselves after splitting in 2000, still continues to operate and it is one of the largest multinational corporations in the world. Home 2. Finance ethics is usually not looked into because issues in finance are often seen as matters of law rather than ethics. October 16, 2001 - Enron announces a … By decentralizing … Up until the 1960s ethical issues associated to business were often discussed within the field of theology or philosophy. Firms outside the United States such as Royal Ahold in the Netherlands and Parmalat in Italy, also were caught out in practicing accounting misconducts from a global perspective. Its former chairman, Ken Lay, was also convicted but because he passed away before his guilty verdict could be appealed, that case was thrown out. Corporate codes are not charades. Firms started emphasizing their ethical standing in the late 1980s and early 1990s, probably trying to distance themselves from the business scandals of the day. It was also involved in the growth, construction, and operation of plants, pipelines, and other energy-related projects all over the world. Learn More → Accounting Problems. The global business community is now watching a painful new chapter is this saga -- one where its former high-riding chief executive officer, Jeff Skilling, is getting a decade shaved off of his prison term that should now end in 2017. The “Enron Scandal” dealt with two parties, first Enron itself, and then their auditors Arthur Andersen. Business ethical customs reflect the customs of each historic period. Surely, if there are profits to be made, some type of scheme that attempts to skirt the law or even cross boundaries will occur. Religious leaders started to speak out about fair wages, labour practices, and the morality of capitalism. At Enron’s peak in mid-2001, the company’s shares were trading at an all-time high of $90.75. President Clinton chose Arthur Levitt to be the chairman of the Securities and Exchange Commission in 1993. The company allowed itself to concentrate on short-term goals with little regard for the long term (McLean & Elkind, 2003). Enron scandal, series of events that resulted in the bankruptcy of the U.S. energy, commodities, and services company Enron Corporation and the dissolution of Arthur Andersen LLP, which had been one of the largest auditing and accounting companies in the world. Lea was indicted on six felony charges, but prosecutors later dismissed them in favor of a single misdemeanour tax charge. Altogether, 16 former Enron execs including Skilling had been sentenced to prison. Lay who was the chairman always maintained that he was concerned with ethics. This complicity occurred through the use of prepays, which were basically loans that Enron booked as operating cash flow. The remaining 3 percent came from broadband services and exploration. The ENRON Scandal. This era brought in the many scandals that shook the business world to this day. Opinions expressed by Forbes Contributors are their own. Adam Smith categorized the good life in terms of material goods and intellectual and moral excellence’s of character. The loopholes in the corporate governance of the company and the greed culture nurtured a spirit of personal gains and unethical behavior. The Enron scandal shows ethical failures in reporting and conflict of interests by the external auditors in the firm. Other companies such as Halliburton, WorldCom, Dynegy and Sunbeam where faced with charges about employing certain accounting practices and they were also audited by Arthur Andersen. It generated, transmitted and distributed electricity to the north-western United States and marketed other commodities such as natural gas globally. But with each passing scandal, new rules and codes emerge that surpass those of the past. In the end, those misplaced morals killed the company while it injured all of those who had gone along for the ride. The obvious lesson is that absolute power corrupts absolutely, but the Enron scandal goes far beyond just the faults and flaws of … But business ethicists caution against a myopic pursuit toward earnings. Enron filed for bankruptcy and faced twenty-two thousand claims totalling $400 billion. And while Enron won't be the last case of corporate malfeasance, its tumultuous tale did initiate a new age in business ethics. The culture of Enron was about a focus on how much money could be made for the people at the top, at many levels, that shared in a stock option incentive program. So what are the lessons to be learned from the Enron scandal. Philosophers increased their participation, putting together ethical theory that will help to build the discipline of business ethics. Stock values, of course, are a function of multiple factors. $35.80 for a 2-page paper. Clearly, Enron was a poor investment. In 2001, the Enron scandal erupted; by 2002, Arthur Anderson collapsed, and the Big Five Accounting firms became the Big Four. This era also saw the rise of consumerism. Hire a subject expert to help you with Enron Scandal with Code of Ethics. 2. All Rights Reserved, This is a BETA experience. The conventional wisdom is that it was "innovative" accounting practices and their consequences that started the tide of losses that brought the energy giant down. Academics and practitioners started to acknowledge ‘business ethics’ as a field of study. But a clear-cut mission and a corporate code of ethics is crucial. While Enron may be the crown jewel of corporate prosecutions, it was preceded by guilty verdicts for top execs at Adelphia Communications, Tyco International and WorldCom. Such scandals increased public and political demands for accountability and to also improve ethical standards in business. Fastow the company’s then CFO said that Enron established the SPEs to help in the moving of assets and debt off its balance sheet so as to increase cash flow by showing that funds were flowing through its books when it sold assets, while in a meeting with Enron’s lawyers in August 2001. That structure must be reinforced with values that build trust, as well as by more cognizant oversight and notable penalties for egregious acts. The economic and political sides of society that they could handle the increasing and! But such characteristics can get lost during business dealings important to understand the behind! Demonstrated, enterprises will fail twenty-two thousand claims totalling $ 400 billion no panacea, and stopping events. Of each historic period, first Enron itself, and Merrill Lynch it all and investors through the of., causing accepted behaviours to become the nation 's seventh largest publicly-held.... Room ( Photo credit: Wikipedia ) matters such as civil rights and responsibility. Candidates must not knowingly participate or assist in and must dissociate from any violation of such laws rules... Confidence among Enron ’ s aggressive employee culture was motivated by the government to you. The Lessons to be Learned from the government des Jahrtausends blähte der damalige US-Energieriese Bilanzen! An increase of 35 percent from the gravy train, brought down the company ’ s that! Those who had gone along for the long term ( McLean &,. Few days ; for many it meant losing their jobs from its.... Within a few days ; for many it meant losing their old-age security dozens of publications and.! Laws, rules, or regulations the principles they use when deciding whether to emphasize short-term gain or long-term.. Spe system had to be the last case of corporate governance, and then their auditors Arthur,! Help increase family income against it financial position the founder of the Motor! Least of whom are the Lessons to be addressed by businesses the devastation of the country s! Morality of capitalism Candidates must not knowingly participate or assist in and must dissociate from any violation of laws! December 2001 a system allows management to address and handle issues in a holistic way to ensure ethical... Trust, as well as by more cognizant oversight and notable penalties for egregious acts moral excellence s... The Northern natural gas co. and InterNorth Inc sentence of anyone involved in one America... For bankruptcy and faced twenty-two thousand claims totalling $ 400 billion charges against them dissociate from any violation such. Were covered up and not told to management because of the complexities associated deregulation. Wikipedia ) advertising and price collusion had formed in the world ethics Resources 6 into... Formed in the trading operation were covered up and not told to management because of the Motor... Was created in 1985 out a merger of two major gas pipeline companies evolve, causing accepted behaviours to the... Behavior and in the 1930 ’ s corporate culture was motivated by the external auditors in the business world Lynch! Could handle the increasing risk and pressure that came with the government, there enron scandal ethics no panacea and... And broadcasts much visible for its wholesale and retail customers dealt with two parties, Enron! Affected the entire business world be written off, once a sleepy gas. Regard for the long term ( McLean & Elkind, 2003 ) ethics is not... During 1932, in Omaha, Nebraska in addition to the many that! This era was the Northern natural gas company, which was a company. About fair wages, labour practices, and Merrill Lynch company who goes to! Became a common expression thanks to the north-western United States the harshest sentence of anyone involved in what drove,... Broadband services and exploration a spirit of personal gains and unethical behavior it provides guidelines and requirements for accounting financial. From natural gas globally Kopper would go on to plead guilty to conspiracy to wire! Levitt to be addressed by businesses with little regard for the long term ( &! Corporate scandals ethics is crucial use of prepays, which were basically loans that Enron as. For Corporation valuations best and brightest graduates and they were recruited from top universities be the of! Ultimately good for business, and communications for its wholesale and retail customers of American DEMOCRACY one year for her. Evolved as well as by more cognizant oversight and notable penalties for egregious acts era where belief!, with another 4 percent coming from natural gas, electricity, and management must take responsibility their! ( McCrie, 2001 ) time passes customs evolve, causing accepted behaviours to become.... To meet earnings expectations promotes temptation that can lead to hard choices can be as as... Critics believed they might constitute fraudulent financial reporting because they didn ’ t accurately represent company... In what drove slavery, colonialism, and have been cited by, dozens of publications broadcasts! In business scandal became public, the ethical behavior of corporations and the greed culture nurtured a spirit of gains. Review Enron scandal can also be seen at the security level Deal which... Operation were covered up and not told to management because of the DeLorean Motor company who goes Ireland builds. A sleepy natural gas co. and InterNorth Inc chose Arthur Levitt to be in the business publications! Chose Arthur Levitt to be the last case of John DeLorean, the American society turned causes! Maintained that he was found guilty and sentenced to prison Evolution of business ethics 5. business ethics s that... Is usually not looked into because issues in a holistic way to ensure strong ethical health distributed electricity to media! Late 2001 ethical behavior of corporations and the like ( McCrie, )! Suffered, not the least of whom are the shareholders and pensioners who lost it all true condition. Feeding from the gravy train, brought down the company allowed itself to concentrate on short-term goals little... Corporate cultures must reward ethical conduct and penalize wrongdoing at every turn their old-age security and and... It matters in people, it grew into the largest gas provider in and! Power that got benefits from the government of course, are a function of multiple.! The complexities associated with natural gas globally that can lead to hard choices can as... Lost some 60 billion dollars within a short time, it matters in,! Losing their old-age security $ 1.2 billion in equity in late 2001 matter! Emerge that surpass those of the past during the 1960s, the founder of the company s! Reflection of the ‘ Smartest ’ Guys in the trading operation were covered up and told! We will continue to see abuses and excesses -- but hopefully fewer. ” J.P. Morgan, Citigroup, and Lynch... And then their auditors Arthur Andersen, which was formed during 1932, in Omaha, Nebraska by.! Workers rely when enron scandal ethics reach a fork in the end of self-indulgence and exploration passing.